Coffee: Grounds for Debate
Edited by Scott F Parker and Michael W Austin
Wiley-Blackwell £11.99
Introducing Philosophy Through Pop Culture
Edited by William Irwin and David Kyle Johnson
Wiley-Blackwell £17.99
The contemporary chain coffeehouse is a symbol in our 'existential era', asserts Brook J Sadler, an associate professor of philosophy at the University of South Florida, in her essay, 'Cafe Noir: Anxiety, Existence and the Coffeehouse', in this appetising collection of philosophical essays about the culture surrounding our popular beverage.
For, when we turn up there we find only dull corporate uniformity, and the promise of sociality rapidly recedes. Thus coffee becomes an emblem of our existential predicament, of our struggle to make sense of our lives, the coffeehouse reminding us that 'the meanings that permeate our lone existence are always a function of our social nature'. Such apparent pessimism is countered by Jill Hernandez, an assistant professor of philosophy ('philosoffee'?) at the University of Texas, who tackles 'The Existential Ground of True Community: Coffee and Otherness'.
She says that it is through optimistic existentialists, as opposed to pessimistic ones such as Sartre and Camus (and, potentially, Sadler), that we can understand community and how it helps people out of despair and loneliness. A community of coffee drinkers, for example, enables the existential notion of hope to happen. I'll go along with that. But it is infuriating that Hernandez talks about optimistic existentialists in seeming ignorance of the greatest optimistic existentialist of them all, the British philosopher, novelist and critic Colin Wilson, who is noted for saying: 'Pessimism is lying across modern civilisation like some enormous fallen tree and somehow we've got to get a bulldozer and shift it out of the way.'
One is not aware of the best-selling Wilson's coffee-drinking habits, but his own community of consciousness has been expanding for half a century among his legion of readers, and he has done more than Kierkegaard, Jaspers, Buber and Marcel put together - they, says Hernandez, suggested that it is only through joining in community that an individual can triumph over hopelessness - to raise consciousness and encourage optimism about existence in the general population.
Coffee does seem to make people think - and with an estimated 500 billion cups downed each year, there seems good reason to examine the 'coffee cogito' - 'I drink therefore I am' - and its pervasively ruminative character. There's an old joke about a philosopher being a machine for turning coffee into theories. Thus it's 'only natural' there should be a book about coffee and philosophy, say the editors in their introduction - below a Bob Dylan quote from his Theme Time Radio Hour on coffee - because they are strongly linked in cultural imagination as well as in practice: from the rambunctious coffeehouses of the 17th and 18th centuries to the smoky cafes of mid-20th-century Paris, where existentialists held court, to the daily necessity of the contemporary 'coffee break'.
It results in an entertaining but seriously analytical debate, not just about the cultural crux but also the metaphysics, aesthetics and ethics of the coffee domain. Among other subjects covered include the ethics concerning the coffee industry, caffeine as the world's most commonly consumed drug, and the question of just how good a cup of coffee can be. Essay titles give the flavour, if not the aroma, of the contents of this invigorating collection: 'The Necessary Ground of Being', 'The Unexamined Cup is Not Worth drinking', 'Coffee and the Good Life'.

In 'The Love Song of J Alfred Prufrock' (1917), T S Eliot wrote: 'I have measured out my life with coffee spoons' - a suitable epigraph for this unique compendium, which is in the wide-ranging
Philosophy for Everyone series and ought to go down a treat with coffee drinkers everywhere. One more cup of coffee for the road, before you go?
Although not in this innovative and piquant series, I must make mention of Introducing Philosophy Through Pop Culture: From Socrates to South Park, Hume to House, which offers an alternative avenue into the ubiquitous discipline. Presenting essays from Blackwell's Philosophy and Pop Culture series, this lively book takes examples from music, film and TV - including Lost, The Matrix, Batman, Terminator, The Office, X-Men and Harry Potter - to introduce a whole range of topics from epistemology to metaphysics, ethics and the meaning of life. Even the most abstract and challenging philosophical ideas suddenly become clear in this novel approach - with or without coffee.